What next for Poland?

Ruling CoalitionEnvisage a panic-stricken teacher, dishevelled and unkempt hastily writing a report for one of his more tiresome students. However, this is no ordinary report and this is no ordinary pupil. The pupil is the Republic of Poland and the report is the image that the local (Polish) and international press have created.

The usual clichéd formulas come to the teacher’s mind: must do better, talks too much, never does his homework, bullies other students. These can be roughly understood as Poland’s incapability and unwillingness to reform its economic policy and make life easier for business people; its predilection for bickering, in-fighting and divided politics; its lack of preparation and common sense on the international stage; and finally, its penchant for bigoted and intolerant views.

These are not my opinions but the opinions of the majority of the world’s press. As part of my love of corpus linguistics, I decided to collect text examples of articles that use the word Poland or Polish. I’m not even near completing this gargantuan project but I have already noted a marked difference in the content of articles written up to the year 1989, those written after the fall of the Berlin Wall and prior to EU enlargement and those written after the borders opened to Poland’s eager workers coinciding nicely with the ascension to power of the Holy Trinity Coalition of Law and Justice (PiS), Self-Defence (Samoobrona) and the League of Polish Families (LPR).

Generally speaking, Poland’s reputation has plummeted like a stone. Up to 1989, attitudes oscillated between pity and ignorance; after 1989 these feelings were more akin to hope and fascination; now these attitudes are of astonishment, disgust and desolation. To many, Poland seems to be undoing what it so valiantly managed to achieve after one hundred and twenty-three years of alien occupation, two devastating world wars and fifty years of communism. The freedom that was won through blood, sweat and tears is being seriously challenged not by an alien power but by internal forces focused on nationalism, bigotry, pseudo-Catholicism and a thirst for blood.

The words that seem to most frequently correlate with the words Poland and Polish are quite often neutral but there is a dangerously high number of negative words which also cluster around Poland and Polish. Such words are witch-hunt, inspecting, vetting, scandal, European Commision (nearly always used negatively), immigrants, secret to name just a few. This gives us a linguistic (or more precisely, a semantic) map of the views of the world press, a mind map of sorts.

Below are some examples of the texts that I’ve found:

The Financial Times tells us: “A law that comes into force today will compel board members and managers of listed companies to confess if they had been informants for communist-era secret police. Executives who refuse to co-operate … or who are caught lying about their past would be banned from working for public companies for 10 years.”

The Economist: “The Polish government realises it needs a foreign policy, but doesn’t yet have one.”

The Sun: “A LOOPHOLE means East European migrants living in Britain can claim child benefit – even if their kids don’t live here. Polish migrants alone have made 50,000 claims and thousands from other new EU countries are cashing in. Readers are furious this is being allowed.”

The European Voice: “The Polish have a ghastly history as Europe’s battlefield. Over the centuries the population has had a choice of viewing: oppression and exploitation from the east or the west. When the Germans and Russians can agree, it is from both east and west. Have the Poles learned anything from all this?”

An apt question for Poland’s ruling coalition might be the title of Henryk Sienkiewicz’s masterpiece Qvo Vadis, Latin for ‘where are you going?’

4 thoughts on “What next for Poland?

  1. Some say that history shows that successive Polish regimes/governments have had a tendency to self-implode. Is this just another example of the ever-turning historical cycle?

  2. How often have the Polish people had any choice in the matter? Pilsudski took over a failing parliamentary government and ruled by diktat until his death, then his incompetent fellow staffers tried to do the same until squashed by the Nazis and rolled flat by the Communists. Not to mention the 123 years of partition prior to Pilsudski. No, Poland has never been used to choosing its governments, and now seems (like many former W-Pact countries) to be locked in a hopeless cycle of ‘throw the bums out’. Unfortunately, the country now seems to have completely run out of political alternatives. (Kwasik to the rescue? I hardly think so.)

    The answer will come in a generation. The young people — going abroad to work, with horizons, opportunities and dreams better than any of the previous generations have had — will (invasion by Lukashenka notwithstanding) be in a better position to put this country on a reasonable track again. But in the meantime, we just have to batten down the hatches and wait out the storm.

    PS Me podpisal umowa przedwstepna today! ^^ Wwa here I come…

  3. I agree wholeheartedly with what you say about Poles never having a choice in the matter and so how can one expect democracy to be respected when the average Pole knows little about how democracy really functions in the same way an American, Englishman or French citizen might.
    However, if you believe that this will change in one generation then you’re a more optimistic man than myself. Historical is cyclical whether we like it or not and Poland’s stereotypical problems have a nasty habit of coming back to haunt them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s