Constitution Unchanged, Speaker Resigns

Abortion LawMy, my, what a kerfuffle! Friday the 13th was a truly tainted day for the Polish government yesterday. The Polish political scene has been bubbling for the past few weeks after members of right-wing LPR (League of Polish Families) decided to put forward proposals for an amendment to Articles 30 and 38 of the Polish Constitution. In their view, Articles 30 and 38 should be amended to protect the rights of the unborn child as well as elderly people. Their proposals would in effect put a complete ban on all forms of abortion and euthanasia.

LPR began shoring up support amongst Catholic members of their coalition partners PiS (Law and Justice) and Samoobrona (Self-Defence) as well as Catholic members of the more liberal-minded PO (Civic Platform). The public debate that ensued resembled a political mud-slinging match with right-wing politicians asking their fellow parliamentarians to decide whether they were pro-death or pro-life. The discussion basically became an debate on abortion. The liberals in Poland’s Sejm including most of PO and SLD (Democratic Left Alliance) were all adamant that the present Constitution regulates this issue satisfactorily.

Decision time came yesterday when the Sejm got down to business. Five amendments to the Constitution were put forward – each concerning one or both of Articles 30 and 38, each in some way restricting abortion (which is currently illegal in Poland anyway). Marek Jurek, the Speaker of the House and part of the extreme Catholic wing of PiS (former ZChN member) opened proceedings in sombre mood urging MPs to search their conscience and do the right wing thing. He had previously stated that this vote was the litmus test of Poland’s moral compass and he laid all his cards on the table.

Before the vote, fault lines had already begun to appear in the ruling coalition. All LPR members wanted a complete ban on abortion and euthanasia whereas many PiS members were unsure. Voting began. The first proposal was thrown out. The second proposal also fell at the final hurdle. LPR began to panic and in the recess one of its members started distributing copies of a letter a Polish bishop had written on the evils of abortion leaving them on all the seats of the Sejm. Marek Suski, a PiS politician was so disgusted with the agitation of his coalition colleagues he began collecting the leaflets and ripping them up. The coalition cracks had begun to appear.

Following the recess voting began. The third proposal of amending the Constitution was thrown out, the fourth also fell. PM Jarosław Kaczyński of PiS appealed to members to do the right thing and deputy PM Roman Giertych of LPR also felt the need to say his bit which, in the final analysis, probably consolidating the more liberal-minded PiS members to vote against the fifth proposal which was also thrown out. The fissures were now visible to all.

Soon after voting finished, the Speaker Marek Jurek (of the right-wing PiS faction) called a press conference and announced he would be resigning as Speaker. He had made his non-objective views clear to the House prior to voting. All his eggs were in one basket and all his eggs were broken.

What happens next will be interesting. Experts believe a split within PiS is imminent. Others believe very little will take place as the main opposition party PO does not have the energy to turn PiS’s setback into political weaponry. One thing is clear – LPR’s Roman Giertych has become the undisputed leader of Poland’s right-wing hardcore.

7 thoughts on “Constitution Unchanged, Speaker Resigns

  1. Hm, I didn’t know about Suski’s action. Is he also a leftover from the ZChN?

    I tend to think that _both_ of your final points are true; the PiS will fractionalise, and that the PO will be unable to capitalise on that. I sense another breakdown and re-alignment of the political scene, as happened when the AWS movement disintegrated. I keep telling people to watch Rokita; he makes my flesh creep, but he’ll be the centre of the next major development on the centre-right. Either he’ll seize control of the PO or start something himself.

    I wonder whether something similar will happen on the left; I suspect the SLD as we know it will cease to exist relatively soon, as the ‘barons’ seem desperate to hang on by their clawtips, to the extent of even threatening to dump their chosen puppet Olejniczak from his position as party leader. Despite what the media tell us, there _is_ a left out there in Poland, and they’re not happy with the SLD, or the other weak and irrelevant leftist parties.

  2. Jimbo:
    Suski is most definitely NOT a former member of ZChN. He was very much a part of the more liberlising Porozumienie Centrum (along with the Kaczyńskis), hence his anti-LPR (and also Marek Jurek) actions.
    I think you’re way off the mark with Rokita. He simply doesn’t have the political clout to try anything that would effectively be tantamount to political suicide.
    Yes, we are looking at a bit of a re-alignment. What with all the in-fighting across the board, there is a visible niche forming and it’s somewhere in the centre – we’ll either be witnessing the strengthening of LiD (Borowski, Geremek et al together with Kwaśniewski, I believe) or the disintegration of PiS with the right-wing element fizzing out into nothing thus creating a more tight-knit Porozumienie Centrum Mark II.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s